As someone who begins their Halloween celebrations on September 1st, I know what it’s like to be pushed to the limit when re-watching your favorite scary movies – even if they’re all A24 masterpieces. If you can quote the quote “I am your mother!” If you give a perfect speech next to Toni Collette, maybe it’s time to look at something other than scary Hereditary. Luckily, the A24 archives are rich with twisted, haunting stories that stay with you and easily become new Halloween staples.
Clearly the indie entertainment company knows what it’s doing, with massive horror hits like Midsummer, pearl and most recently the terror-triggering indie flick Talk to me in his spooky catalog. But with all the hype surrounding these bigger titles, you may have missed some of A24’s more underrated scary movies. But fear not, I’ve experienced every single one of these terrible films (with the help and endless persuasion of my college friend Lexie) and am here to recommend some alternatives to your favorite A24 films.
Here are some underrated A24 horror films that you can watch instead of just re-watching Midsummer again this Halloween.
If you liked it Hereditary (2018), consider The Blackcoat’s daughter (2017)
If you liked Ari Aster’s Hereditarya supernatural story about loss, grief and a dark presence that torments a family The Blackcoat’s daughter is for you. Told in three different timelines, the film follows two young students left behind at their remote private Catholic boarding school during winter break, where they are plagued by trauma, grief and possibly something supernatural. Emma Roberts, Kiernan Shipka and Lucy Boynton star in this haunting story. You can stream both The Blackcoat’s daughter And Hereditary At Max.
If you liked it Midsummer (2019), consider Climax (2019)
If you liked the stressful, eerie score and the spooky yet solemn atmosphere that quickly descends into frightening chaos in Ari Aster’s midsummer, Then you can enjoy Gaspar Noé’s wonderfully bloody film Climax.
With Atomic blonde Actress Sofia Boutella’s 2019 film is about a teenage dance troupe who lock themselves in an empty school building on a cold winter evening for an all-night rehearsal and rage. But the beautifully choreographed gathering turns violent and vindictive when the dancers discover that their party punch has been spiked with LSD by one of their own. Climax features an unmissable level of intensity and plenty of flawed but talented characters to cry in horror over. You can rent Climax through Prime Video or check it out for free with a free trial Cinemax add-on.
And if you want to watch Florence Pugh fall into the clutches of a Swedish cult again, you can also rent the film Midsummer At Prime Video.
If you liked it pearl (2022), consider (2019)
I know, I know, but she is a star! No one will judge you for rewatching Ti West’s eccentric prequel to A24 X, starring Mia Goth, David Corenswet, Tandi Wright, Matthew Sunderland and Emma Jenkins-Purro. But if you want to check out another one of A24’s crazy leading ladies, consider it Saint Maud. The 2019 psychological thriller from debut director Rose Glass tells the story of a troubled, devoutly religious young woman who works as a private nurse at a hospice. When the nurse is assigned to a terminally ill atheist with a hedonistic past, she believes she is called to save her patient’s soul by any means necessary. Saint Maud Stars The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Actress Morfydd Clark and Jennifer Ehle. You can stream Saint Maud free up Prime Video.
And when you Do I want to rewatch Goth’s headline-grabbing performance pearlYou can continue streaming it Paramount+.
If you liked it X (2022), hold Green space (2016)
If you loved the extremely violent Xin which a group of aspiring adult filmmakers fight for their lives on a rural farm while being attacked by the deadliest senior citizens of all time, you’ll likely find yourself hooked Green space. Jeremy Saulnier’s 2016 horror film is about a punk band that plays a show after a short show to Far outside of Portland, they witness a murder within the neo-Nazi skinhead “community.” Trapped in the venue’s green room, surrounded by bloodthirsty skinheads, the group has no choice but to fight their way to freedom. Green space It stars Anton Yelchin, Imogen Poots, Alia Shawkat, Joe Cole, Callum Turner and Patrick Stewart. You can stream Green space At Max (For now, the twisted title is leaving HBO’s streaming platform on November 30).
I would like to visit it again X? You can continue streaming the hot slasher Paramount+.
If you liked it Body, body, body (2022), consider Life after Beth (2014)
If you giggled as much as you jumped out of your seat during 2022’s campy horror comedy body, body, body, Then I think you can find it in your probably cynical heart to enjoy it Life after Beth. Aubrey Plaza plays the adorable undead Beth and Dane DeHaan plays Beth’s loving but confused boyfriend Zach. Zach grieves for his girlfriend after she is killed by a snakebite and tries to stay in touch with her parents, only to realize that they are keeping their recently resurrected daughter a secret from him. The scariest thing ever Life after Beth is rom-com level chemistry between Beth and Zach and is clearly a product of our zombie-obsessed mid-2010s, but if you want to see something spooky this Halloween season, the dark zombie comedy will fully satisfy your hunger . Molly Shannon, Cheryl Hines, Paul Reiser, Matthew Gray Gubler and John C. Reilly also star Life after Bethnow on stream Max.
And if you want to watch the hot rich kids (Amandla Stenberg, Maria Bakalova, Myha’la Herrold, Chase Sui Wonders, Rachel Sennott, Lee Pace, and Pete Davidson) frolic around a mansion in the middle of a hurricane before their comedic take Find the end, you can stream Body, body, body At Paramount+.
Why you can trust us: We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we believe in. Price and availability subject to change.